Skip to content
GK24
GK NotesIndian PolityCAG and the Attorney General

CAG and Attorney General: Articles 148 to 151 and 76

Complete notes on the CAG and the Attorney General of India: Articles 148 to 151 and 76, appointment, tenure, removal, audit, advice and exam-ready facts.

By · Published · 5 min read

CAG and Attorney General: Articles 148 to 151 and 76 — GK24 title card
CAG and Attorney General: Articles 148 to 151 and 76 — GK24 title card

Two offices stand between the government and the two things it must answer for, the money it spends and the law it relies on. The Comptroller and Auditor General audits every rupee the Union and the states draw from their consolidated funds, and the Attorney General advises the Union on law and appears for it in the Supreme Court. One is deliberately insulated from the government, with a fixed term and a judge like removal; the other deliberately is not, and holds office during the pleasure of the President. Dr B. R. Ambedkar called the Comptroller and Auditor General the most important officer under the Constitution, and examiners treat the pair as one chapter because almost every question turns on the contrast between them.

The Comptroller and Auditor General: Articles 148 to 151

The office was modelled on the British office of the same name and sits in Part V, Chapter V of the Constitution. Article 148 creates it, Article 149 lets Parliament prescribe its duties and powers, Article 150 gives it a say in the form in which the accounts of the Union and the states are kept, and Article 151 governs its reports. Parliament passed the Comptroller and Auditor General (Duties, Powers and Conditions of Service) Act in 1971 under Article 149.

ArticleSubject
148Appointment, oath and conditions of service of the CAG
149Duties and powers, as prescribed by Parliament
150Form of accounts of the Union and the states
151Audit reports to the President and to the Governors

The President appoints the CAG by warrant under his hand and seal, and the CAG makes an oath before the President in the form set out in the Third Schedule. The term is six years or up to the age of sixty five, whichever comes first. Removal follows the same manner and the same grounds as the removal of a judge of the Supreme Court, which means an address by each House supported by a special majority on the ground of proved misbehaviour or incapacity, so no government can remove an inconvenient auditor on its own. The salary is equal to that of a judge of the Supreme Court, it cannot be reduced during the term, and the salary, pension and administrative expenses of the office are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India, so Parliament does not vote on them. Article 148(4) adds a rule candidates forget: after holding office the CAG is not eligible for any further office under the Government of India or of any state.

What the CAG audits and reports

The CAG audits the expenditure and the receipts of the Union and of every state, the trading and manufacturing accounts of government departments, the accounts of bodies and authorities substantially financed from public revenues and of government companies and corporations where the law allows, and it heads the Indian Audit and Accounts Department. Audit and accounts were separated in 1976, so for the Union the CAG now audits and no longer keeps the accounts. Its reports on Union accounts go to the President, who causes them to be laid before each House of Parliament, and its reports on a state go to the Governor, who causes them to be laid before the state legislature. In Parliament they are examined by the Public Accounts Committee, whose work depends so completely on these reports that the CAG is called the friend, philosopher and guide of that committee, and the guardian of the public purse.

The Attorney General: Article 76

Article 76 makes the Attorney General the first law officer of the Government of India. The President appoints a person qualified to be appointed a judge of the Supreme Court, and the Attorney General holds office during the pleasure of the President with remuneration the President determines, so the Constitution fixes neither a term nor a removal procedure; by convention the office changes with the government. The duties are to advise the Government of India on legal matters referred to him, to perform such duties of a legal character as the President assigns, and to discharge the functions the Constitution or any law confers. He appears for the Union in the Supreme Court and in any High Court in cases concerning the Union.

Under Article 88 the Attorney General has the right to speak in and take part in the proceedings of both Houses of Parliament, any joint sitting and any committee of which he is named a member, but he has no right to vote, and under Article 105 he enjoys the privileges and immunities of a member of Parliament. He is not a member of the Cabinet and not a whole time government servant, so he may take private practice, but he cannot advise or hold a brief against the Government of India, cannot defend an accused in a criminal prosecution or accept a company directorship without the government permission. The Solicitor General of India and the Additional Solicitors General assist him, and a point worth marking is that they find no mention in the Constitution, which names only the Attorney General. For a state the corresponding officer is the Advocate General under Article 165, appointed by the Governor.

The two offices compared

PointCAGAttorney General
Article148 to 15176
Appointed byPresident, by warrant under hand and sealPresident
TermSix years or age 65During the pleasure of the President
RemovalLike a judge of the Supreme CourtNo procedure prescribed
OathYes, before the PresidentNo oath prescribed
Later officeBarred under the Union or a stateNot barred
ParliamentNo right to sit or speakMay speak but not vote, Article 88

Exam Point of View

The sharpest questions set the two offices against each other, so hold the contrast ready: the CAG has a six year term, an oath, a judge like removal and a bar on later office, while the Attorney General has none of these and holds office during the pleasure of the President. Article numbers are asked directly, 148 for the CAG, 151 for his reports, 76 for the Attorney General, 88 for his right to speak and 165 for the Advocate General of a state. A recurring trap is the destination of the audit report, which goes to the President for the Union but to the Governor for a state, and another is the claim that the Attorney General is a member of the Cabinet, which he is not. Expect the borrowed feature question, the office of the CAG from Britain, and the Public Accounts Committee link. Also remember that the Solicitor General is a statutory and not a constitutional post, and that the CAG audits but no longer keeps the accounts of the Union after the separation of 1976.

Important Facts

Articles for the CAG148 to 151, Part V, Chapter V
CAG tenureSix years or till the age of 65, whichever is earlier
CAG removalSame manner as a judge of the Supreme Court
CAG salaryEqual to a judge of the Supreme Court, charged on the Consolidated Fund of India
Bar after officeNo further office under the Union or any state, Article 148(4)
Governing ActCAG (Duties, Powers and Conditions of Service) Act, 1971, under Article 149
Union audit reportTo the President, laid before each House of Parliament
State audit reportTo the Governor, laid before the state legislature
First CAG of independent IndiaV. Narahari Rao
Separation of audit and accounts1976
Article for the Attorney General76
Attorney General qualificationQualified to be appointed a judge of the Supreme Court
Attorney General tenureDuring the pleasure of the President; no term fixed
Right in ParliamentMay speak and take part under Article 88, but cannot vote
State counterpartAdvocate General, Article 165, appointed by the Governor

Practice MCQs on this topic

Q1.Indian PolityAsked in: Uttar Pradesh · UPPSC Civil Service 2016 Official PaperMedium

Who among the following holds his or her office during the pleasure of the President?

  1. A.Comptroller and Auditor General of India
  2. B.Chief Election Commissioner
  3. C.Speaker of Lok Sabha
  4. D.Attorney General of India
Show answer
Correct answer: D. Attorney General of India

Article 76 says he is appointed by the President and holds office during the pleasure of the President, and the Constitution prescribes neither a fixed term nor any procedure for his removal.

Q3.Indian PolityAsked in: Delhi · 15 Oct 2018, Shift 3Easy

The office of the Comptroller and Auditor General in the Indian Constitution has been borrowed from which country?

  1. A.Britain
  2. B.Ireland
  3. C.Canada
  4. D.Australia
Show answer
Correct answer: A. Britain

The framers took the office of the Comptroller and Auditor General, along with parliamentary government, the rule of law, single citizenship and the writs, from the British Constitution, where an officer of the same name audits public spending for Parliament.

Q4.Indian PolityAsked in: Delhi · 11 Nov 2019, Shift 3Easy

The reports of the CAG of India relating to the accounts of a state shall be submitted to the ______.

  1. A.Governor of the state
  2. B.Chief Minister of the state
  3. C.Finance Minister of the state
  4. D.Chief Economic Advisor of the state
Show answer
Correct answer: A. Governor of the state

Article 151(2) says the reports of the Comptroller and Auditor General relating to the accounts of a state shall be submitted to the Governor, who shall cause them to be laid before the legislature of the state.

Q6.Indian PolityMedium

The Comptroller and Auditor General of India holds office for a term of

  1. A.five years or till the age of 62, whichever is earlier
  2. B.six years or till the age of 65, whichever is earlier
  3. C.six years only, irrespective of age
  4. D.till the age of 70
Show answer
Correct answer: B. six years or till the age of 65, whichever is earlier

Under the Comptroller and Auditor General (Duties, Powers and Conditions of Service) Act of 1971, made under Article 149, he holds office for six years from the date he enters upon it or till he attains the age of sixty five years, whichever is earlier.

Q7.Indian PolityMedium

The Comptroller and Auditor General of India can be removed from office in the same manner as

  1. A.a judge of the Supreme Court
  2. B.a member of the Union Public Service Commission
  3. C.the Attorney General of India
  4. D.a Governor of a state
Show answer
Correct answer: A. a judge of the Supreme Court

Article 148(1) says the CAG shall be removed from office only in like manner and on the like grounds as a judge of the Supreme Court, which means an address by each House of Parliament supported by a majority of the total membership and by two thirds of the members…

Q8.Indian PolityHard

Which of the following is true of the Comptroller and Auditor General after he leaves office?

  1. A.He may be appointed to any office under the Union but not under a state
  2. B.He is not eligible for any further office under the Union or any state government
  3. C.He is automatically appointed a judge of the Supreme Court
  4. D.He becomes an ex officio member of the Public Accounts Committee
Show answer
Correct answer: B. He is not eligible for any further office under the Union or any state government

Article 148(4) provides that the Comptroller and Auditor General shall not be eligible for further office either under the Government of India or under the government of any state after he has ceased to hold his office.

Q9.Indian PolityMedium

The Comptroller and Auditor General of India is described as the friend, philosopher and guide of which parliamentary committee?

  1. A.Estimates Committee
  2. B.Committee on Public Undertakings
  3. C.Public Accounts Committee
  4. D.Business Advisory Committee
Show answer
Correct answer: C. Public Accounts Committee

That committee examines the appropriation and finance accounts of the Union along with the audit reports of the CAG, and since its entire work begins from those reports and his officers assist it in understanding them, he is called its friend, philosopher and guide.

Q10.Indian PolityEasy

Which article of the Constitution deals with the Attorney General of India?

  1. A.Article 72
  2. B.Article 76
  3. C.Article 78
  4. D.Article 88
Show answer
Correct answer: B. Article 76

It provides for the appointment of the Attorney General for India by the President from among persons qualified to be appointed a judge of the Supreme Court, states his duty to advise the Government of India on legal matters, and says he holds office during the pleasure of the President…

Q11.Indian PolityMedium

Which statement about the Attorney General of India in Parliament is correct?

  1. A.He can speak and vote in both Houses
  2. B.He can speak in both Houses but cannot vote
  3. C.He can attend only the Rajya Sabha
  4. D.He has no right to enter either House
Show answer
Correct answer: B. He can speak in both Houses but cannot vote

Article 88 gives the Attorney General the right to speak in and otherwise take part in the proceedings of both Houses of Parliament, in any joint sitting and in any committee of which he is named a member, and Article 105 extends the privileges and immunities of a member to…

Q12.Indian PolityMedium

Who is the highest law officer of a state government and under which article is the office created?

  1. A.Advocate General, under Article 165
  2. B.Solicitor General, under Article 76
  3. C.Attorney General, under Article 165
  4. D.Public Prosecutor, under Article 148
Show answer
Correct answer: A. Advocate General, under Article 165

The Governor appoints a person qualified to be a judge of a High Court as Advocate General of the state, to advise the state government on legal matters and to perform the legal duties the Governor assigns; he holds office during the pleasure of the Governor and may speak in…

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the tenure of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India?

Six years from the date he enters office, or till he attains the age of sixty five years, whichever comes first. He may resign earlier by writing to the President, and he can be removed only in the same manner as a judge of the Supreme Court, that is by an address of each House supported by a special majority on the ground of proved misbehaviour or incapacity.

To whom does the CAG submit his audit reports?

Reports relating to the accounts of the Union go to the President, who causes them to be laid before each House of Parliament, where the Public Accounts Committee examines them. Reports relating to the accounts of a state go to the Governor of that state, who causes them to be laid before the state legislature. This split of President and Governor is governed by Article 151.

Why is the CAG called the guardian of the public purse?

Because no money drawn from the Consolidated Fund escapes his audit. He checks whether the money was spent on the purpose Parliament voted it for and within the amount voted, and his reports let the legislature hold the executive to account. Dr B. R. Ambedkar described the office as the most important under the Constitution for the same reason.

What qualification does the Attorney General of India need?

He must be a person qualified to be appointed a judge of the Supreme Court. That means a citizen of India who has been a judge of a High Court for five years, or an advocate of a High Court for ten years, or a distinguished jurist in the opinion of the President. He need not have actually been a judge.

Can the Attorney General take part in the proceedings of Parliament?

Yes. Article 88 gives him the right to speak in and take part in the proceedings of both Houses, any joint sitting and any parliamentary committee of which he is named a member, and Article 105 gives him the privileges of a member. He has no right to vote, because he is not a member of either House.

Is the Solicitor General of India a constitutional post?

No. The Constitution names only the Attorney General in Article 76. The Solicitor General and the Additional Solicitors General assist him and are appointed by the government, so theirs is not a constitutional office, a distinction papers test often.

Sources

View all