Skip to content
GK24
GK NotesIndian PolityUPSC and State Public Service Commissions

UPSC and State Public Service Commissions: Articles 315-323

Complete notes on UPSC and the State Public Service Commissions: Articles 315 to 323, appointment, tenure, removal, functions, expenses and exam-ready facts.

By · Published · 5 min read

UPSC and State Public Service Commissions: Articles 315-323 — GK24 title card
UPSC and State Public Service Commissions: Articles 315-323 — GK24 title card

The Constitution does not leave recruitment to the higher civil services to the government of the day. It creates a Union Public Service Commission for the Union and a Public Service Commission for every state, gives their members a fixed tenure, a difficult removal procedure and expenses charged on the Consolidated Fund, and then asks them to advise on appointments and promotions. The machinery is old: India's first Public Service Commission was set up on 1 October 1926 on the recommendation of the Lee Commission, which is why merit-based recruitment in India completed a hundred years in 2026. Articles 315 to 323 in Part XIV of the Constitution carry the whole scheme, and examiners ask more from these nine articles than from anything else in the chapter.

Articles 315 to 323 at a glance

ArticleSubject
315Public Service Commissions for the Union and for the States
316Appointment and term of office of members
317Removal and suspension of a member
318Power to make regulations as to conditions of service
319Prohibition on holding office after ceasing to be a member
320Functions of Public Service Commissions
321Power to extend the functions of Commissions
322Expenses of Public Service Commissions
323Reports of Public Service Commissions

How the Commissions grew

The Lee Commission of 1924 recommended a statutory Public Service Commission, and one was established on 1 October 1926 under the Government of India Act, 1919. The Government of India Act, 1935 renamed it the Federal Public Service Commission and provided for provincial commissions. On 26 January 1950 it became the Union Public Service Commission under the Constitution. The Commissions are therefore older than the Republic, and the Constitution merely gave them protection they did not have before.

Appointment, strength and tenure

The chairman and other members of the UPSC are appointed by the President; those of a State Public Service Commission are appointed by the Governor of the state. The Constitution fixes neither the strength of a Commission nor the qualifications of its members, leaving the number to the President or the Governor. It lays down only one condition about composition: as nearly as may be, one-half of the members must be persons who have held office under the Government of India or under a state government for at least ten years.

A member of the UPSC holds office for six years from the date he enters upon office, or until he attains the age of sixty-five years, whichever is earlier. For a State Commission or a Joint Commission the age limit is sixty-two years, the term being the same six years. A member may resign in writing to the President in the case of the UPSC and to the Governor in the case of a State Commission. Conditions of service are determined by the President or the Governor under Article 318, but they cannot be varied to a member's disadvantage after appointment.

Removal and the guarantee of independence

Only the President can remove the chairman or a member of a Commission, and this is true of a State Commission as well: a Governor appoints an SPSC member but cannot remove one. Removal for misbehaviour is possible only after the Supreme Court, on a reference by the President, holds an inquiry and reports; the Court's advice binds the President. A member may also be removed if he is adjudged an insolvent, engages during his term in paid employment outside the duties of his office, or is in the President's opinion unfit to continue by reason of infirmity of mind or body. Pending a Supreme Court inquiry, the President may suspend a member of the UPSC and the Governor may suspend a member of an SPSC.

Notice what is missing: Parliament plays no part in removing a member of a Public Service Commission. Judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts and the Comptroller and Auditor General are removed by the President only after an address by both Houses; a Commission's member is not. Article 322 adds a second protection by charging the expenses of a Commission, including the salaries and pensions of its staff, on the Consolidated Fund of India or of the state, so they are not submitted to the vote of the legislature. Article 319 adds a third: a retiring chairman of the UPSC is ineligible for any further employment under the Union or a state.

Functions under Articles 320, 321 and 323

  • Conducting examinations for appointments to the services of the Union and of the states.
  • Being consulted on methods of recruitment, on the principles to be followed in appointments, promotions and transfers, and on the suitability of candidates for them.
  • Being consulted on disciplinary matters affecting a civil servant, and on claims for legal costs and for pensions in respect of injuries suffered in service.
  • Presenting an annual report of its work: the UPSC to the President, who lays it before Parliament, and an SPSC to the Governor, who lays it before the state legislature, together with a memorandum explaining any case in which the advice was not accepted.

The advice of a Commission is advisory only and does not bind the government, which is why the memorandum of non-acceptance matters. Article 320 allows the President or the Governor to make regulations specifying the matters in which a Commission need not be consulted, and such regulations must be laid before the legislature for at least fourteen days. Under Article 321 additional functions may be conferred on the UPSC by Parliament and on a State Commission by that state's legislature. Two or more states may ask Parliament to create a Joint State Public Service Commission, whose chairman and members are appointed by the President, and under Article 315(4) the UPSC may serve a state's needs if the Governor requests it and the President approves.

UPSC and a State Commission compared

PointUPSCState Commission
Appointed byPresidentGovernor
Removed byPresidentPresident
Suspended during inquiry byPresidentGovernor
Age limit for a member65 years62 years
Annual report toPresidentGovernor
Expenses charged onConsolidated Fund of IndiaConsolidated Fund of the state

The UPSC conducts the Civil Services Examination, the Indian Forest Service Examination, the Engineering Services, Combined Medical Services and Combined Geo-Scientist examinations, the Indian Economic Service and Indian Statistical Service examinations, the Combined Defence Services and National Defence Academy examinations and the Central Armed Police Forces (Assistant Commandants) examination, besides recruitment by selection through interview.

Exam Point of View

Examiners test article numbers first: 315 constitution, 316 appointment and term, 317 removal, 318 conditions of service, 319 bar on later employment, 320 functions, 321 extension of functions, 322 expenses, 323 reports. The commonest trap is the removal of a State Commission's member, where the answer is the President after a Supreme Court inquiry and not the Governor, and the second commonest is the age limit, 65 for the UPSC against 62 for a State Commission. Questions also compare the Commissions with the judges and the CAG to show that Parliament has no role here, ask which fund the expenses are charged on, and ask whether the advice binds the government. Remember that Article 321 names Parliament for the UPSC and the state legislature for an SPSC.

Important Facts

Constitutional partPart XIV, Articles 315 to 323
First Public Service CommissionSet up 1 October 1926, after the Lee Commission of 1924
Became UPSC26 January 1950, under the Constitution
Appointment of UPSC membersBy the President, Article 316(1)
Appointment of SPSC membersBy the Governor of the state, Article 316(1)
TenureSix years, or age 65 for the UPSC and 62 for a State or Joint Commission, whichever is earlier
Composition conditionAbout half the members must have held office under the Union or a state for at least ten years
RemovalOnly by the President, Article 317; for misbehaviour after a binding Supreme Court inquiry
Suspension pending inquiryPresident for a UPSC member, Governor for an SPSC member
ExpensesCharged on the Consolidated Fund of India or of the state, Article 322
Extension of functionsArticle 321: by Parliament for the UPSC, by the state legislature for an SPSC
Annual reportArticle 323: UPSC to the President and Parliament, SPSC to the Governor and the state legislature
Bar after officeArticle 319: a retiring UPSC chairman cannot take further government employment
Joint CommissionCreated by Parliament on the request of two or more state legislatures; members appointed by the President

Practice MCQs on this topic

Q1.Indian PolityAsked in: Uttar Pradesh · UPPSC Civil Services GS Official Paper IMedium

In the removal of which of the following officials does the Parliament not play any role?

1. Judges of the High Court
2. Judges of the Supreme Court
3. Chairman of the Union Public Service Commission
4. Comptroller and Auditor General of India

Choose the correct answer from the codes given below.

  1. A.Only 1 and 2
  2. B.Only 3 and 4
  3. C.Only 1, 2 and 3
  4. D.Only 3
Show answer
Correct answer: D. Only 3

The chairman of the Union Public Service Commission is removed by the President under Article 317, and for misbehaviour only after the Supreme Court has held an inquiry on the President's reference and reported against him.

Q2.Indian PolityAsked in: SSC GD Constable · 01 Feb 2023, Shift 3Easy

The tenure of the UPSC members is:

  1. A.6 years or age of 65 whichever is earlier
  2. B.6 years or age of 62 years
  3. C.5 years or age of 65 years
  4. D.4 years or age of 62 years
Show answer
Correct answer: A. 6 years or age of 65 whichever is earlier

Article 316(2) says that a member of the Union Public Service Commission holds office for a term of six years from the date on which he enters upon his office, or until he attains the age of sixty-five years, whichever is earlier.

Q3.Indian PolityAsked in: Uttar Pradesh · 24 Oct 2021Medium

The functions of the State Public Service Commission of Uttar Pradesh can be extended by:

  1. A.Prime Minister
  2. B.Union Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions
  3. C.The President
  4. D.Uttar Pradesh State Legislature
Show answer
Correct answer: D. Uttar Pradesh State Legislature

Article 321 allows additional functions to be conferred on a Public Service Commission, and it names two different authorities for the two kinds of Commission: Parliament may extend the functions of the Union Public Service Commission, while the legislature of a state may extend the functions of that state's Public…

Q4.Indian PolityAsked in: Uttar Pradesh · 24 Oct 2021Medium

A member of State Public Service Commission may be removed by:

  1. A.The Governor on the basis of impeachment in Vidhan Sabha
  2. B.The Governor, after the enquiry conducted by the Supreme Court
  3. C.The President, after the enquiry conducted by the Supreme Court
  4. D.The Governor, after the enquiry conducted by the High Court
Show answer
Correct answer: C. The President, after the enquiry conducted by the Supreme Court

Article 317(1) provides that the chairman or any other member of a Public Service Commission, whether of the Union or of a state, shall be removed from office only by order of the President on the ground of misbehaviour, and only after the Supreme Court has held an inquiry on…

Q5.Indian PolityEasy

Which Article of the Constitution of India provides for Public Service Commissions for the Union and for the States?

  1. A.Article 312
  2. B.Article 315
  3. C.Article 320
  4. D.Article 324
Show answer
Correct answer: B. Article 315

It is the opening article of the group on Public Service Commissions and says that there shall be a Public Service Commission for the Union and a Public Service Commission for each state, with the further provision that two or more states may have a Joint Commission created by Parliament…

Q6.Indian PolityMedium

The expenses of the Union Public Service Commission, including the salaries and pensions of its staff, are:

  1. A.Voted by the Lok Sabha every year
  2. B.Charged on the Consolidated Fund of India
  3. C.Met from the Contingency Fund of India
  4. D.Shared between the Union and the states
Show answer
Correct answer: B. Charged on the Consolidated Fund of India

Article 322 makes the expenses of the Union Public Service Commission, including the salaries, allowances and pensions payable to or in respect of its members and staff, charged expenditure on the Consolidated Fund of India.

Q7.Indian PolityMedium

Under Article 323, the annual report of a State Public Service Commission on its work is presented to the:

  1. A.President, who lays it before Parliament
  2. B.Chief Minister of the state
  3. C.Governor, who lays it before the state legislature
  4. D.Union Public Service Commission
Show answer
Correct answer: C. Governor, who lays it before the state legislature

Article 323(2) requires a State Commission to present to the Governor an annual report of the work done by it, and the Governor then places it before the state legislature together with a memorandum explaining the cases, if any, in which the Commission's advice was not accepted and the reasons…

Q8.Indian PolityEasy

A member of a State Public Service Commission holds office for six years or until he attains the age of:

  1. A.60 years
  2. B.62 years
  3. C.65 years
  4. D.70 years
Show answer
Correct answer: B. 62 years

Article 316(2) fixes a six-year term for every Public Service Commission but two different retiring ages: sixty-five years for a member of the Union Public Service Commission and sixty-two years for a member of a State Commission or of a Joint Commission, and in each case the earlier of the…

Q9.Indian PolityMedium

Which one of the following is not a function of the Union Public Service Commission under Article 320?

  1. A.Conducting examinations for appointments to the services of the Union
  2. B.Advising on the principles to be followed in promotions and transfers
  3. C.Making the final appointment of selected candidates to a service
  4. D.Advising on disciplinary matters affecting a civil servant
Show answer
Correct answer: C. Making the final appointment of selected candidates to a service

The Commission recommends; the appointing authority of the government issues the appointment.

Q10.Indian PolityHard

A Joint State Public Service Commission for two or more states can be created by:

  1. A.The President on the advice of the Union Cabinet
  2. B.Parliament by law, on a request by the legislatures of those states
  3. C.The Governors of the states concerned acting together
  4. D.The Union Public Service Commission by regulation
Show answer
Correct answer: B. Parliament by law, on a request by the legislatures of those states

Article 315(2) says that if the legislatures of two or more states pass resolutions to that effect, Parliament may by law provide for the appointment of a Joint State Public Service Commission to serve the needs of those states.

Q11.Indian PolityHard

India's first Public Service Commission was set up in 1926 on the recommendation of which body?

  1. A.The Islington Commission
  2. B.The Lee Commission
  3. C.The Simon Commission
  4. D.The Sapru Committee
Show answer
Correct answer: B. The Lee Commission

The Royal Commission on the Superior Civil Services in India, headed by Lord Lee of Fareham and reporting in 1924, recommended the setting up of a statutory Public Service Commission, and the first Public Service Commission in India was accordingly established on 1 October 1926 under the Government of India…

Q12.Indian PolityMedium

Which Article prohibits the chairman of the Union Public Service Commission from taking further employment under the Government of India or a state after ceasing to hold office?

  1. A.Article 317
  2. B.Article 318
  3. C.Article 319
  4. D.Article 322
Show answer
Correct answer: C. Article 319

It bars the holding of certain offices after a member ceases to be one, and its first clause makes a retiring chairman of the Union Public Service Commission ineligible for any further employment either under the Government of India or under a state government.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who removes a member of a State Public Service Commission?

The President, and only the President, even though the Governor makes the appointment. For misbehaviour the President must first refer the case to the Supreme Court, and the Court's report binds him. The Governor may suspend the member while that inquiry is on, but cannot remove him.

What is the tenure of a UPSC member?

Six years from the date of entering office, or until the age of sixty-five years, whichever comes earlier. For a State Public Service Commission or a Joint Commission the age limit is sixty-two years, with the same six-year term.

Is the advice of the UPSC binding on the government?

No. The Commission only advises. Where the government does not accept the advice, it must place before Parliament a memorandum explaining the reasons, along with the Commission's annual report under Article 323.

Which article provides for a Joint State Public Service Commission?

Article 315(2). Parliament may create one by law if two or more state legislatures pass resolutions requesting it. Its chairman and members are appointed by the President, and it reports to the Governor of each of the states concerned.

Why are the expenses of the Commissions charged on the Consolidated Fund?

To protect their independence. Under Article 322 the salaries, allowances and pensions of a Commission's chairman, members and staff are charged expenditure, so the legislature discusses but does not vote on them and cannot reduce them to put pressure on the Commission.

Can a UPSC member take another government job after retiring?

Article 319 restricts it. A retiring chairman of the UPSC is ineligible for further employment under the Union or a state. A UPSC member may become chairman of the UPSC or of a State Commission but nothing else, and a State chairman may become chairman or member of the UPSC or chairman of another State Commission.

Sources

View all