Skip to content
GK24
GK NotesIndian HistoryIndian National Congress: Moderates and Extremists

Moderates and Extremists in the Indian National Congress

Notes on the Indian National Congress from 1885 to 1916: its founding and early sessions, the Moderates, the Extremists, the Surat split and the Lucknow reunion.

By · Published · 6 min read

Moderates and Extremists in the Indian National Congress — GK24 title card
Moderates and Extremists in the Indian National Congress — GK24 title card

The Indian National Congress was founded on 28 December 1885 at the Gokuldas Tejpal Sanskrit College in Bombay, with 72 delegates present and Womesh Chunder Bonnerjee in the chair. Lord Dufferin was the Viceroy, and the retired Indian Civil Service officer Allan Octavian Hume had done the organising; the body he first planned was called the Indian National Union. For the next twenty years the Congress was led by men who trusted British justice and asked for reform by argument. After 1905 a second group, impatient with asking, demanded swaraj and was ready to boycott. The quarrel between the two broke the Congress at Surat in 1907 and was patched up at Lucknow in 1916. This chapter is a chapter of names, years and sessions, and examiners test exactly those.

Before 1885: the associations that led up to the Congress

The Congress did not appear out of nothing. The British Indian Association was formed at Calcutta in 1851, the East India Association by Dadabhai Naoroji in London in 1866, the Poona Sarvajanik Sabha in 1870, the Indian Association by Surendranath Banerjea and Anandamohan Bose in 1876, the Madras Mahajan Sabha in 1884 and the Bombay Presidency Association in 1885 by Pherozeshah Mehta, K. T. Telang and Badruddin Tyabji. These bodies trained a generation in petitioning, in the press and in public meetings. The Congress gathered them into one all-India platform that met every December in a different city.

Year and sessionPresidentWhy it is remembered
1885, BombayW. C. BonnerjeeFirst session, 72 delegates
1886, CalcuttaDadabhai NaorojiGrand Old Man of India in the chair
1887, MadrasBadruddin TyabjiFirst Muslim president
1888, AllahabadGeorge YuleFirst English president
1896, CalcuttaRahimtulla SayaniVande Mataram sung for the first time
1906, CalcuttaDadabhai NaorojiSwaraj declared the goal
1907, SuratRashbehari GhoshThe split between Moderates and Extremists
1916, LucknowAmbica Charan MajumdarReunion, and the Lucknow Pact with the Muslim League
1917, CalcuttaAnnie BesantFirst woman president of the Congress

The Moderates, 1885 to 1905

Dadabhai Naoroji, Gopal Krishna Gokhale, Surendranath Banerjea, Pherozeshah Mehta, M. G. Ranade, Dinshaw Wacha and Badruddin Tyabji led this phase. Their method has been summed up as the three Ps, prayer, petition and protest: resolutions at the annual session, memorials to the Government, speeches in the councils and propaganda in England, where a British Committee of the Congress and the journal India put the Indian case before Parliament. Their faith was that British rule had been a blessing in its principles and a failure in its practice, so once the facts were known the wrong would be righted. Naoroji supplied the strongest fact of all in his drain theory, set out in Poverty and Un-British Rule in India, that a stream of wealth was flowing out of the country every year as home charges, pensions and profits. He also became the first Indian elected to the British House of Commons, in 1892. The Moderates asked for the expansion of the legislative councils, Indianisation of the services and simultaneous civil service examinations in India and England, lower land revenue and salt tax, and more spending on education. They won a little: the Indian Councils Act of 1892 enlarged the councils and allowed indirect election in all but name, a resolution for simultaneous examinations was passed in the House of Commons in 1893, and the Welby Commission was appointed to look into Indian expenditure. Gokhale, whom Gandhi called his political guru, founded the Servants of India Society in 1905.

Why the Extremists rose

By 1900 a younger generation had lost patience with what Tilak called political mendicancy. Several things pushed them. The reforms of 1892 were plainly inadequate. Famine and plague between 1896 and 1900 killed millions while the administration seemed unmoved. Lord Curzon offended educated India with the Calcutta Corporation Act of 1899, the Indian Universities Act of 1904 and the Official Secrets Amendment Act of 1904, and then partitioned Bengal in 1905. Events abroad destroyed the myth of European invincibility: Abyssinia defeated Italy in 1896, the Boers fought the British to a standstill, and Japan defeated Russia in 1905. Indian scholarship, meanwhile, had restored pride in the ancient past.

Lal, Bal and Pal, and the methods of the Extremists

The trio of Lala Lajpat Rai, Bal Gangadhar Tilak and Bipin Chandra Pal gave the new school its voice, with Aurobindo Ghose beside them. Tilak, called Lokmanya, edited Kesari in Marathi and Maratha in English, began the Ganapati festival in 1893 and the Shivaji festival in 1895 to carry politics to ordinary people, was sentenced in 1908 to six years of transportation in Mandalay, where he wrote Gita Rahasya, and gave the cry that Swaraj is my birthright and I shall have it. Lala Lajpat Rai, the Punjab Kesari, was an Arya Samajist, was deported to Mandalay in 1907 and wrote The Story of My Deportation and Young India. Bipin Chandra Pal edited New India, and Aurobindo Ghose wrote in Bande Mataram and set out the Doctrine of Passive Resistance. Their goal was swaraj, their method swadeshi, boycott, national education and passive resistance, and their faith was in self-reliance rather than in petitions. The Congress session at Calcutta in 1906, with Naoroji in the chair, accepted swaraj as the goal and approved swadeshi and boycott, which was the Extremists' first victory inside the Congress.

The Surat split and the Lucknow reunion

At Surat in December 1907 the two groups could not agree on the president or on how far the Swadeshi and boycott resolutions of Calcutta should go. The session broke up in disorder, Rashbehari Ghosh was declared president, and the Extremists were pushed out of the Congress. The Government struck at once with the Seditious Meetings Act of 1907 and the Newspapers Act of 1908, jailed Tilak and deported Lajpat Rai, while the Morley-Minto reforms of 1909 tried to win the Moderates over and introduced separate electorates for Muslims. The Congress remained weak until the deaths of Pherozeshah Mehta and Gokhale in 1915, Tilak's return from prison in 1914 and the Home Rule agitation brought the two wings together at the Lucknow session of 1916, where the Congress and the Muslim League also signed the Lucknow Pact.

Moderates and Extremists compared

  • Goal: the Moderates asked for self-government within the Empire, the Extremists for swaraj.
  • Method: constitutional agitation and petitions against swadeshi, boycott, national education and passive resistance.
  • Base: the Moderates spoke for an educated urban class, the Extremists reached students, traders and the lower middle class.
  • Attitude to British rule: the Moderates thought it providential in design, the Extremists thought it a source of India's poverty.

Exam Point of View

Questions from this chapter are of four kinds. First, the founding: the date 28 December 1885, the place, the 72 delegates, Hume as the organiser, Bonnerjee as the first president and Dufferin as the Viceroy. Second, the firsts: first Muslim president Badruddin Tyabji, first English president George Yule, first woman president Annie Besant in 1917 and first Indian woman president Sarojini Naidu in 1925. Third, the leaders and their writings and papers: Naoroji with Poverty and Un-British Rule in India, Tilak with Kesari, Maratha and Gita Rahasya, Lajpat Rai with Young India, Pal with New India and Aurobindo with Bande Mataram. Fourth, the sessions: Calcutta 1906 for swaraj, Surat 1907 for the split with Rashbehari Ghosh in the chair, and Lucknow 1916 for the reunion and the pact with the Muslim League. The usual traps swap the year of the split with the year of the reunion, make Sarojini Naidu the first woman president, or credit the Moderates with boycott and the Extremists with petitions.

Important Facts

Foundation28 December 1885, Gokuldas Tejpal Sanskrit College, Bombay; 72 delegates
Founder and organiserAllan Octavian Hume, a retired Indian Civil Service officer
First presidentWomesh Chunder Bonnerjee (W. C. Bonnerjee)
Viceroy in 1885Lord Dufferin
First Muslim presidentBadruddin Tyabji, 1887, Madras session
First English presidentGeorge Yule, 1888, Allahabad session
Moderate leadersNaoroji, Gokhale, Surendranath Banerjea, Pherozeshah Mehta, Ranade, Dinshaw Wacha
Extremist leadersLala Lajpat Rai, Bal Gangadhar Tilak, Bipin Chandra Pal, Aurobindo Ghose
Tilak's papersKesari in Marathi and Maratha in English; Gita Rahasya written in Mandalay jail
Swaraj as the goalCalcutta session, 1906, president Dadabhai Naoroji
The splitSurat session, December 1907; Rashbehari Ghosh declared president
The reunionLucknow session, 1916, president Ambica Charan Majumdar; Lucknow Pact signed
First woman presidentAnnie Besant, Calcutta session, 1917
Servants of India SocietyFounded by Gopal Krishna Gokhale in 1905

Practice MCQs on this topic

Q1.Indian HistoryAsked in: SSC GD Constable · 5 March 2019, Shift 2Easy

Which British retired Civil Service Officer took the initiative to convene the first meeting of the Indian National Union?

  1. A.John Morley
  2. B.Edwin Montagu
  3. C.Allan Octavian Hume
  4. D.Gilbert Elliot
Show answer
Correct answer: C. Allan Octavian Hume

A retired officer of the Indian Civil Service who had served in the North-Western Provinces, Hume issued an appeal to the graduates of Calcutta University in 1883, organised the body he called the Indian National Union, and brought its first session together at Bombay in December 1885, where it took…

Q2.Indian HistoryAsked in: SSC CGL · 13 Dec 2022, Shift 4Medium

How many delegates attended the first session of Congress in 1885?

  1. A.62
  2. B.78
  3. C.68
  4. D.72
Show answer
Correct answer: D. 72

The first session of the Indian National Congress met at the Gokuldas Tejpal Sanskrit College in Bombay from 28 to 31 December 1885 and was attended by 72 delegates, most of them lawyers, journalists, teachers and merchants drawn from the presidency towns, with W. C. Bonnerjee presiding.

Q4.Indian HistoryAsked in: Delhi · 1 Oct 2021, Shift 2Easy

Who was the first woman President of the Indian National Congress?

  1. A.Kasturba Gandhi
  2. B.Sarojini Naidu
  3. C.Annie Besant
  4. D.Aruna Asaf Ali
Show answer
Correct answer: C. Annie Besant

The Irish-born theosophist, who had made India her home and led the Theosophical Society from Adyar, presided over the Calcutta session of the Congress in 1917, the year in which the Government interned her for her Home Rule agitation.

Q6.Indian HistoryEasy

Who gave the slogan 'Swaraj is my birthright and I shall have it'?

  1. A.Bipin Chandra Pal
  2. B.Lala Lajpat Rai
  3. C.Bal Gangadhar Tilak
  4. D.Aurobindo Ghose
Show answer
Correct answer: C. Bal Gangadhar Tilak

He edited Kesari in Marathi and Maratha in English, used the Ganapati festival from 1893 and the Shivaji festival from 1895 to take politics to the streets, was sentenced in 1908 to six years of transportation at Mandalay, where he wrote Gita Rahasya, and founded his Home Rule League in…

Q9.Indian HistoryMedium

The Servants of India Society was founded in 1905 by which leader?

  1. A.Gopal Krishna Gokhale
  2. B.M. G. Ranade
  3. C.Pherozeshah Mehta
  4. D.Dinshaw Wacha
Show answer
Correct answer: A. Gopal Krishna Gokhale

He founded the Servants of India Society at Poona in 1905 to train men who would give their lives to public service on a modest allowance, and he worked through the Imperial Legislative Council on the budget, on primary education and on the conditions of indentured labour.

Q10.Indian HistoryMedium

The drain theory, explaining Indian poverty as the outflow of wealth to England, was put forward in which book?

  1. A.Poverty and Un-British Rule in India by Dadabhai Naoroji
  2. B.A Nation in Making by Surendranath Banerjea
  3. C.Gita Rahasya by Bal Gangadhar Tilak
  4. D.Young India by Lala Lajpat Rai
Show answer
Correct answer: A. Poverty and Un-British Rule in India by Dadabhai Naoroji

The Grand Old Man of India argued in it that a steady drain of wealth, through home charges, pensions paid in England, interest on sterling debt and the profits of British firms, was the real cause of Indian poverty, and the argument became the Moderates' strongest weapon.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who founded the Indian National Congress and when?

Allan Octavian Hume, a retired officer of the Indian Civil Service, took the initiative, and the first session met on 28 December 1885 at the Gokuldas Tejpal Sanskrit College in Bombay with 72 delegates. W. C. Bonnerjee presided and Lord Dufferin was the Viceroy of the day.

What is the difference between the Moderates and the Extremists?

The Moderates, who led the Congress from 1885 to 1905, wanted self-government within the British Empire and worked by petitions, resolutions and propaganda in England. The Extremists, who rose after 1905, demanded swaraj and used swadeshi, boycott, national education and passive resistance, holding that British rule itself was the cause of India's poverty.

Why did the Congress split at Surat in 1907?

The two groups disagreed on the choice of president and on how far the Swadeshi and boycott resolutions of the Calcutta session of 1906 should be carried. The Surat session of December 1907 broke up in disorder, Rashbehari Ghosh was declared president and the Extremists were excluded; the two wings came together again only at Lucknow in 1916.

What is the drain theory and who gave it?

Dadabhai Naoroji gave it in Poverty and Un-British Rule in India. He showed that a large part of India's wealth was drained away every year through home charges, pensions paid in England, interest on debt and the profits of British firms, so that Indian poverty was a result of the economic working of British rule, not of nature.

Who was the first woman president of the Indian National Congress?

Annie Besant, who presided over the Calcutta session of 1917. She founded the Home Rule League in 1916, edited New India and Commonweal, and was interned by the Government in 1917. Sarojini Naidu, who presided at Kanpur in 1925, was the first Indian woman to hold the office.

Sources

View all