In which case did the Supreme Court hold that judicial review is a part of the basic structure of the Constitution while striking down parts of the 42nd Amendment?
- A.Golaknath case, 1967
- B.Minerva Mills case, 1980
- C.Shankari Prasad case, 1951
- D.Maneka Gandhi case, 1978
Correct answer
Explanation
The correct answer is B, the Minerva Mills case of 1980. In Minerva Mills v. Union of India the Supreme Court struck down the provisions inserted by the 42nd Amendment Act of 1976 which had declared that no constitutional amendment could be called in question in any court and had given Parliament unlimited amending power, holding that both judicial review and the limited nature of the amending power belong to the basic structure. Option A is wrong because Golaknath, decided in 1967, held that Fundamental Rights could not be abridged by amendment and is remembered for the doctrine of prospective overruling, but it predates both the 42nd Amendment and the basic structure doctrine. Option C is wrong because Shankari Prasad of 1951 upheld the First Amendment and took the opposite view of the amending power. Option D is wrong because Maneka Gandhi of 1978 expanded the meaning of personal liberty under Article 21.
Read the full article: Writs and Judicial Review: Articles 32, 226 and PYQs
Practice Questions
View allWhich writs in the Indian Constitution mean To be informed or To be certified?
- A.Prohibition
- B.Quo-Warranto
- C.Certiorari
- D.Habeas Corpus
Show answer
Certiorari is Latin for to be certified or to be informed, and the writ does exactly that: a higher court calls up the record of a case from a lower court or tribunal, either to transfer the matter to itself or to quash an order already passed because of excess…
Read the full explanation →Power of issuing a writ of Habeas Corpus lies with
- A.Supreme Court
- B.High Courts
- C.District and Session Court
- D.Both (A) and (B)
Show answer
Habeas corpus can be issued by the Supreme Court under Article 32, where it is a remedy for the breach of the Fundamental Right to personal liberty, and by every High Court under Article 226, which covers Fundamental Rights and any other purpose as well.
Read the full explanation →Which article of the Constitution of India is known as the right to constitutional remedies?
- A.Article 19
- B.Article 32
- C.Article 226
- D.Article 14
Show answer
Article 32 guarantees the right to move the Supreme Court for the enforcement of Fundamental Rights and empowers the Court to issue directions, orders and writs for that purpose, which is why it is titled the right to constitutional remedies and why Dr B. R. Ambedkar described it as the…
Read the full explanation →Which one of the following writs is issued only against judicial or quasi-judicial authorities and never against an administrative or legislative body?
- A.Mandamus
- B.Prohibition
- C.Habeas corpus
- D.Quo warranto
Show answer
Prohibition means to forbid. It is issued by a superior court to a lower court or a tribunal to stop it from continuing with a proceeding that lies beyond its jurisdiction, so by its nature it can be directed only at bodies exercising judicial or quasi-judicial functions, never at an…
Read the full explanation →Against which of the following can the writ of mandamus NOT be issued?
- A.A municipal corporation
- B.An inferior court
- C.The President of India
- D.A statutory tribunal
Show answer
Mandamus means we command, and it is issued to a public body or official to perform a public duty that it has refused to perform.
Read the full explanation →