In the Minerva Mills case of 1980, the Supreme Court struck down which clauses of Article 368?
- A.Clauses 1 and 2
- B.Clauses 2 and 3
- C.Clauses 3 and 4
- D.Clauses 4 and 5
Correct answer
Explanation
The correct answer is D, clauses 4 and 5. The Forty-second Amendment had added clause 4, saying that no amendment shall be called in question in any court, and clause 5, saying that the amending power of Parliament was unlimited. In Minerva Mills the Court struck down both, holding that judicial review and the limited nature of the amending power are themselves part of the basic structure.
Option A is wrong because clauses 1 and 2 are the original provisions on the amending power and the procedure, and they remain in force. Option B and Option C are wrong because clause 3, which says that Article 13 shall not apply to an amendment, was inserted by the Twenty-fourth Amendment and was not struck down. The neat way to hold this is that the Forty-second Amendment added clauses 4 and 5 and Minerva Mills removed exactly those two.
Read the full article: Constitutional Amendment and Basic Structure: Article 368
Practice Questions
View allThe procedure for amending the Constitution of India is laid down in which Article?
- A.Article 356
- B.Article 360
- C.Article 368
- D.Article 370
Show answer
It is titled Power of Parliament to amend the Constitution and procedure therefor, and it sets out both the special majority needed in each House and the cases in which the legislatures of the states must also ratify the change.
Read the full explanation →Article 368 of the Constitution of India falls in which Part?
- A.Part XVIII
- B.Part XIX
- C.Part XX
- D.Part XXI
Show answer
Part XX of the Constitution is a very short part, headed Amendment of the Constitution, and it contains Article 368 alone.
Read the full explanation →The doctrine of the basic structure of the Constitution was laid down by the Supreme Court in which case?
- A.Shankari Prasad case, 1951
- B.Golaknath case, 1967
- C.Kesavananda Bharati case, 1973
- D.Minerva Mills case, 1980
Show answer
A bench of thirteen judges, the largest ever assembled at the time, held by a majority of seven to six that Parliament may amend any part of the Constitution, including the Fundamental Rights, but may not damage or destroy its basic structure.
Read the full explanation →Which earlier judgment was overruled by the Supreme Court in the Kesavananda Bharati case?
- A.Golaknath case
- B.Berubari Union case
- C.S. R. Bommai case
- D.Minerva Mills case
Show answer
In Golaknath in 1967 an eleven judge bench held by six to five that Parliament had no power to amend the Fundamental Rights.
Read the full explanation →By which amendment was the President's assent to a Constitution Amendment Bill made obligatory?
- A.Twenty-fourth Amendment, 1971
- B.Twenty-fifth Amendment, 1971
- C.Forty-second Amendment, 1976
- D.Forty-fourth Amendment, 1978
Show answer
It was passed in answer to the Golaknath ruling. It amended Article 13 and Article 368 to make clear that Parliament could take away or abridge a Fundamental Right by amendment, and it made the President's assent to such a bill compulsory, so an amendment bill can neither be withheld…
Read the full explanation →