In the Berubari Union case of 1960, the Supreme Court held that ceding Indian territory to a foreign State requires
- A.only a law under Article 3
- B.a constitutional amendment
- C.a resolution of the State legislature
- D.a decision of the Inter-State Council
Correct answer
Explanation
The correct answer is B, a constitutional amendment. The President sought the advisory opinion of the Supreme Court on whether the agreement to transfer part of the Berubari Union to Pakistan could be carried out under Article 3. The Court held that giving away Indian territory to a foreign country is not a mere diminution of the area of a State under Article 3, because it reduces the territory of India itself, and so it needs an amendment of the Constitution. Option A is wrong for exactly that reason. Option C is wrong because the views of a State legislature are advisory even in an ordinary reorganisation. Option D is wrong because the Inter-State Council has no such power. Parliament accordingly passed the Ninth Constitutional Amendment Act in 1960, and used the same route in 2015 through the Hundredth Constitutional Amendment Act for the Land Boundary Agreement with Bangladesh.
Read the full article: The Union and Its Territory: Articles 1 to 4 and PYQs
Practice Questions
View allWhich of the following is NOT possible by a law of Parliament under Article 3 of the Constitution?
- A.Formation of new States
- B.Alteration of areas of States
- C.Alternation of boundaries of States
- D.Admission of new States
Show answer
Article 3 deals only with territory that is already part of India.
Read the full explanation →Article 1 of the Constitution of India describes India as a
- A.Federation of States
- B.Union of States
- C.Confederation of States
- D.Quasi-federal State
Show answer
Article 1 says that India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States, and the Drafting Committee chose that phrase with care.
Read the full explanation →Which Article of the Constitution empowers Parliament to admit into the Union, or establish, new States?
- A.Article 1
- B.Article 2
- C.Article 3
- D.Article 4
Show answer
Article 2 provides that Parliament may by law admit into the Union, or establish, new States on such terms and conditions as it thinks fit.
Read the full explanation →A Bill to form a new State under Article 3 can be introduced in Parliament only
- A.after a resolution of the State legislature
- B.on the recommendation of the President
- C.with the consent of the Rajya Sabha
- D.on the recommendation of the Inter-State Council
Show answer
The proviso to Article 3 lays down two conditions. First, such a Bill may be introduced in either House only on the recommendation of the President.
Read the full explanation →A law made under Article 3 that alters the First Schedule of the Constitution is passed by
- A.a simple majority, and is not deemed an amendment of the Constitution
- B.a special majority under Article 368
- C.a special majority and ratification by half the States
- D.a two-thirds majority of the Rajya Sabha alone
Show answer
Article 4 states that a law made under Article 2 or Article 3 may contain provisions for amending the First Schedule, which lists the States and Union territories, and the Fourth Schedule, which allots Rajya Sabha seats, and that no such law shall be deemed to be an amendment of…
Read the full explanation →