Skip to content
GK24
Indian PolityMedium

If a State law on a subject in the Concurrent List is repugnant to a law made by Parliament, which of the following is correct?

  1. A.The State law prevails in that State
  2. B.Both laws become void
  3. C.The law made by Parliament prevails and the State law is void to the extent of the repugnancy
  4. D.The Supreme Court must decide which law applies in each case

Correct answer

C. The law made by Parliament prevails and the State law is void to the extent of the repugnancy

Explanation

The correct answer is C. Article 254(1) lays down that where a State law is repugnant to a law made by Parliament on a Concurrent subject, the parliamentary law prevails and the State law is void to the extent of the inconsistency. Option A is wrong as a general statement, though there is a narrow exception in Article 254(2): a State law reserved for the President and given assent prevails in that State, and even then Parliament may override it later by a fresh law. Option B is wrong because the central law is untouched; only the repugnant part of the State law falls. Option D is wrong because the rule of supremacy is written into the Constitution and does not depend on a judicial choice in each case, although courts do apply the doctrine of pith and substance to test whether a real conflict exists.

Read the full article: Centre–State Relations: Articles 245 to 293 and PYQs

View all
Q1.Indian PolityAsked in: Uttar Pradesh · 24 Aug 2021, Shift 2Medium

Which one of the following is not included in the state list in the Constitution of India?

  1. A.Police
  2. B.Law and Order
  3. C.Prison
  4. D.Criminal Procedure Code
Show answer
Correct answer: D. Criminal Procedure Code

Criminal procedure is an entry of the Concurrent List, List III of the Seventh Schedule, along with criminal law and the law of evidence, which is why the code of criminal procedure has always been a central law that States may amend with the President's assent.

Q4.Indian PolityMedium

The Commission on Centre-State Relations appointed in 1983 was chaired by whom?

  1. A.Justice M. M. Punchhi
  2. B.Justice R. S. Sarkaria
  3. C.Dr P. V. Rajamannar
  4. D.K. Santhanam
Show answer
Correct answer: B. Justice R. S. Sarkaria

The Union government appointed a three-member Commission on Centre-State Relations in 1983 under Justice Rajinder Singh Sarkaria, a retired judge of the Supreme Court; it submitted its report in 1988 and recommended a permanent Inter-State Council, sparing use of Article 356, and consultation with States before legislating on Concurrent subjects.

Q5.Indian PolityHard

Under Article 249, Parliament may legislate on a subject in the State List if the Rajya Sabha passes a resolution supported by

  1. A.a simple majority of the members present and voting
  2. B.two-thirds of the members present and voting
  3. C.two-thirds of the total membership of the House
  4. D.three-fourths of the members present and voting
Show answer
Correct answer: B. two-thirds of the members present and voting

Article 249 provides that if the Rajya Sabha declares by a resolution supported by not less than two-thirds of the members present and voting that it is necessary or expedient in the national interest, Parliament may make a law on a matter in the State List; such a law stays…